Skip to Content

Whoa Buddy!

I went out with this guy from Plenty Of Fish who said is car was in the shop so we took the bus. He wanted to show me how the bus worked since I was new to the city. We went to the mall and got some pizza. We went for a short walk afterwards and it started to get cold.

He took me into the porn shop to warm up and tried to kiss me in the "gay section." .... He kept talking about how he couldn't take me to his place because of his roommates, but something seemed fishy about that. I told him he had to explain his "roommates" or it couldn't go any further. He told me that he lives with him parents. I asked out of curiosity where would we hang out... He said, "In my car or in the bus." WEIRDO.

Your alias: 
anonymous
You: 
Female
Your Date: 
Male
Where you met: 
Plenty Of Fish
Average: 4.2 (22 votes)

Merry Christmas For All (But Me)

I was with this fine girl for 7 months, she was everything I wanted. She had kids from a earlier marriage but that was no big deal. Well as you all know Christmas is around the corner so I wanted to get the kids awesome gifts. I got an electric scooter for the boy and a wood kitchen set for the girl.

Thanksgiving came and I wasn't invited to her family's get together; this should have been my first clue. The next couple of weeks went by without me hardly seeing her so I asked if she still likes me and is happy with being with me; she said yes. Last week her and the kids came by we had what I thought was a fun time. When they left early I didn't think much of it. In reality she was there getting all her personal items.

Your alias: 
Alone For Christmas
You: 
Male
Your Date: 
Female
Where you met: 
Book Store
Average: 4.1 (8 votes)

Oh Look, My Parents And Kids Just Happen To Be Here!

I am in my mid 30's, educated, independent, have never been married with no children. I went out on a limb and quit looking for someone of my age with the same characteristics as far as marriage and children are concerned. I met a female and had a wonderful message correspondence for a few days prior to agreeing to meet for a Saturday afternoon lunch. We covered most all of the typical stuff via email, I knew she was divorced with two children (10 & 13), worked in a professional business setting (I admit I never dug too deep via email to find out exactly in respect to privacy) and was living in her parents second home, but not with her parents. Being the economic times we are in, I could understand the financial trouble of a single parent and the living arrangement, I took it as a sign as coming from a close family that helped out when they could.

Your alias: 
E.B. in Michigan
You: 
Male
Your Date: 
Female
Where you met: 
Plenty Of Fish
Average: 4.1 (7 votes)

Drug Addict And Unemployed

I thought I was meeting an educated man who didn't smoke or drink or do drugs. We met and he seemed so good and turned out to be too good to be true. He said he didn't drink but does and has a liver problem too. He said he didn't do drugs but smokes pot all day.

He said he was educated and working and turns out he is at home all day on disability. He seemed good but glad he came clean and told me. I was nice but will never talk to him again.

Your alias: 
anonymous
You: 
Female
Your Date: 
Male
Where you met: 
Plenty Of Fish
Average: 3.8 (4 votes)

Another Troll On Plenty Of Fish

I was contacted by a guy on Plenty of Fish and he wanted to meet up. I usually don't go for meeting people the very first day I talk to them and this goes to show the exact reason I will NOT ever do it again! He asked me to come to his house...mistake one; plus it was pretty late at night.

Anyway, as soon as I saw him I started getting bad vibes from the start. He didn't look much like his pictures at all. He was "astonished" that I'm a girl and I know how to handle guns (I've grown up with guns my whole life). Anyway, he pulls out a Colt 45 revolver that was his great-grandfather's or something like that. Naturally I loved the gun being a revolver person. He then pulls out a .45 semi automatic. He said we could fire them off in his backyard, even though he lived in city limits.

Your alias: 
anonymous
You: 
Female
Your Date: 
Male
Where you met: 
Plenty Of Fish
Average: 2.3 (6 votes)

Deceitful Bitch!

I am in my late 30's. I always convinced myself I never got married because I was waiting for my soul-mate. Finally I thought I had found her on Plenty Of Fish of all places.

We dated and then got very serious after a few months. Close to a year into the relationship I decided to propose. I went online to see if I could open my old Plenty Of Fish account to find out what day we actually met.

My account was gone but on the very first page wouldn't you know her photo pops up in the recently online section! I nearly went ballistic when I read her profile and saw she was currently online... from work no less!

I thought ok, maybe there is some reasonable explanation. To test her I made up a fake profile and sent her an email. Within 2 minutes she emails back and is ready for action.

What a slut!

Needless to say I have returned her ring and dumped her.

Your alias: 
anonymous
You: 
Male
Your Date: 
Female
Where you met: 
Plenty Of Fish
Average: 4.5 (11 votes)
Syndicate content